Prohibit Acquitted Conduct From Enhancing Criminal Penalties, Petition Asks Supreme Court
A convicted criminal with support from politically conservative organizations has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to “put an end” to the judicial practice of enhancing criminal penalties based on jury-acquitted conduct.
Supreme Court Asked to Consider Relevance of Victim’s View in Qualified Immunity Analysis
If at least four of the nine justices vote to grant Deputy Anthony Mumphard’s petition, the U.S. Supreme Court will order the parties to fully brief and argue the issues. The Court will then decide the case this term.
U.S. Supreme Court Will Consider “Independent Source” Exception Test
Deciding the test for the “independent source” exception to the exclusionary rule is before the U.S. Supreme Court this term as the justices review an unopposed petition.
Fourth Circuit Rules MSPB Can't Adjudicate "Mixed Case" of EEO Claims, IRA Appeals
The Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) lacks jurisdiction to address equal employment opportunity (EEO) claims in “individual right of action” whistleblower reprisal appeals, the Fourth Circuit recently held.
Seventh Circuit Finds Terry Stop at Gunpoint Warranted by Circumstances
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit recently held that conducting a stop and frisk at gunpoint was reasonable based on officers’ observations of a suspect’s conduct.
Fifth, Sixth Circuits Split on DHS Immigration Enforcement Guidance
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth and Sixth Circuits are divided on temporarily halting the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) from enforcing its arrest and deportation guidance.
Supreme Court Narrows Lawsuits Against Federal Employees in Personal Capacity
The U.S. Supreme Court’s sweeping decision in Egbert v. Boule precludes almost any new kinds of Bivens claims against federal employees, opening the door to a future overturn.
Federal Circuit Holds MSPB Must Consider Actual Job Duties in LEO Retirement Decisions
The Federal Circuit recently held the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) must acknowledge actual job duties to satisfy primary position criteria as position descriptions are not always current.
Person’s Presence in Suspect Building Insufficient for a Terry Stop, Seventh Circuit
A person’s presence in the same building with some potential connection to a fugitive fails to establish “particularized suspicion” to warrant a Terry stop, the Seventh Circuit held last week.
Judge Blocks DHS Guidance On Discretion in Deportation Decisions
A federal judge has enjoined the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) from enforcing a deportation prioritization directive to Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
Supreme Court Set to Decide Whether Certain Tribal Prosecutions Implicate Double Jeopardy Protection
Supreme Court justices were critical during oral argument of allowing the federal government to prosecute a defendant in federal court previously convicted in a federally-operated tribal court.
11th Circuit Holds Warning Not Always Required Before Using Deadly Force
The Eleventh Circuit wrote that it could not view the officer’s actions “with the 20/20 vision of hindsight” and that qualified immunity leaves “room for mistaken judgments.”
DNI Updates Marijuana-Related Security Clearance Guidance
Agencies received additional adjudicative guidance on three marijuana-related issues recently from the Director of National Intelligence (DNI), in its capacity as the Security Executive Agent.
Supreme Court Rejects Request to Reverse Bivens
The U.S. Supreme Court rejected certiorari on Petitioner Erik Egbert’s request for the Court to reverse Bivens, the 1971 case that allows federal employees to be sued in their personal capacities for violating certain constitutional rights.
Supreme Court May Reconsider 'Bivens' this Term
Bivens may be under reconsideration as the U.S. Supreme Court re-circulated a petition asking the high court to do just that. The petition argues the Ninth Circuit went too far by expanding Bivens, an ideal vehicle to overturn.
Federal Circuit Rules “Willful” and “Intentional” are Not Synonymous
The Federal Circuit affirmed the removal of an Internal Revenue Service (IRS) employee who wrongly believed that the prohibition on disclosure of taxpayer information did not apply if the disclosure was made to her attorney.
TSA Gives Screening Personnel MSPB Appeal Rights
The Transportation Security Administration (TSA) and the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) have reached an agreement granting Title 5 equivalent appeal rights.
Congressional Authority to Regulate Intra-Territory Cockfighting Before the Supreme Court
To establish the “ultimate discovery” exception to the exclusionary rule, the government must prove the exception by a “preponderance of the evidence,” the Eleventh Circuit recently held in an en banc decision. The full-court decision reversed forty-one years of Circuit precedent.
Eleventh Circuit Reverses Itself on ‘Ultimate Discovery’ Standard of Proof
To establish the “ultimate discovery” exception to the exclusionary rule, the government must prove the exception by a “preponderance of the evidence,” the Eleventh Circuit recently held in an en banc decision. The full-court decision reversed forty-one years of Circuit precedent.
Supreme Court Asked to Consider Relevance of Officer Training, Subjective Knowledge to Qualified Immunity Defense
Whether law enforcement officers are entitled to qualified immunity when they knowingly violated their training by retaliating against a person for filming an arrest the officers made in public, was submitted this month for the U.S. Supreme Court’s consideration.